You May Like
1887 N172 Old Judge Frank Wells Milwaukee GRADED PSA Authentic Altered RARE
$449.98
View Details
VINTAGE c. 1887 GOODWIN OLD JUDGE BASEBALL CARD J. ARUNDEL CATCHER. INDIANAPOLIS
$251.95
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE Henry "Hank" Gastreich Columbus AA SGC pose 181-1 RARE
$299.99
View Details
1886 1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball TOM DALY CHICAGO WHITE SOX SGC 1 1500+ HIT
$505.75
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE DUKE P. MINNEAPOLIS POOR
$299.99
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Cal Broughton SGC 1.5 - FAIR
$360.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Jack Glasscock SGC 2.5 - GD+
$920.00
View Details
1887-1889 Old Judge N172 #266-1 Phillip Knell SGC 2 St. Josephs Rare Player Pose
$399.95
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 John Sowders SGC 1.5 - FAIR
$320.00
View Details
1887-1889 N172 Old Judge Walt Wilmot Tobacco Baseball Card Washington Rebacked
$299.99
View Details
RARE 1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JOHN BARNES MGR. ST PAULS SGC 1.5
$845.75
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Leon Viau SGC 1.5 - FAIR
$360.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Bill Vinton - SGC 5.5 EX+
$1147.50
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Nat Hudson Browns PSA 3 - VG
$810.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Gus Albert SGC 1.5 - FAIR
$320.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Baseball Card BILL BISHOP Pittsburgh PSA 2
$845.75
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge #425-5 Germany Smith – Throw Right Hand Chin High - GD
$385.00
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE SAMUEL BARKLEY KANSAS CITY PSA 1 POP 1 ULTRA RARE
$525.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Robert Gilks SGC 3 - VG
$500.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Jack Clements SGC 1.5 - FAIR
$380.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge William Pop Schriver PSA 7 - POP 1, none higher - Phila
$1500.00
View Details
1887-90 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Egyptian Healey (Healy), Indianapolis Hoosiers
$2.50
View Details
1887-90 Old Judge N172 50 Card Starter Set 4 - VG/EX BSET
$28200.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Baseball Card BOB CARUTHERS Brooklyns PSA 1.5 CAREER 218-99
$1185.75
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Bill Schildknecht PSA 2 - GOOD
$480.00
View Details
1887 OLD JUDGE ERNEST BURCH NNO VG N172 SGC 3 BASEBALL ST. LOUIS WHITES
$1440.00
View Details
💥 Sir Hugh Duffy 1887 N172 Old Judge Braves HOF Rookie SGC 1.5
$1550.00
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card PHILLIP KNELL ST. JOSEPHS SGC Authentic
$420.75
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge FRED PFEFFER Chicago Cubs PSA 3 VG Condition
$699.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Henry Gruber PSA 2 - GOOD
$480.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge FRANK DWYER Chicago Cubs PSA 1.5 Fair Condition
$499.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card THOMAS BURNS BROOKLYN TROLLEY DODGERS SGC 3 VG
$760.75
View Details
1887-89 Old Judge Germany Smith SGC Authentic #425-3 Brooklyn New York N172
$525.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 John Sowders SGC 5 - EX
$960.00
View Details
1887 N174 Old Judge Jack McAuliffee HOF NICE!! SGC 4 !!
$399.99
View Details
1887-1889 Old Judge N172 Germany Smith - SGC 5.5 EX+
$1057.50
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Fred Pfeffer PSA 2 - GOOD
$435.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Amos Rusie SGC 40 VG 3 - Hall of Famer
$14999.95
View Details
1887-90 N172 Old Judge William Holbart Catching PR
$299.99
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Jumbo Schoeneck SGC 3 - VG
$690.00
View Details
RARE BASEBALL UMPIRE CARD 1887 Old Judge N172 WALLACE FESSENDEN SGC 4.5 VG/EX
$1275.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Pud Galvin SGC 20 - stunning card!!
$10000.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Bill Stemmeyer - SGC 60
$594.00
View Details
1887-90 Old Judge n172 - n173 Over 4400 Different Images on One USB Drive
$275.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Cigarettes Jack Clements Bat at Ready Nearly Vertical PSA 5
$1500.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card John SOWDERS Kansas City Cowboy PSA 5 Centered
$1615.00
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JAMES MCQUAID Denver SGC 2.5
$675.75
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Whitacre SGC Authentic Vintage Baseball Card Philadelphia As
$404.99
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge "Handsome" Henry Boyle End Of Pitch SGC 4
$1000.00
View Details
RARE 1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Jack Farrell Washington Senators NM MINT PSA 8
$8415.00
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card JACK FARRELL BALTIMORES SGC 3 VG
$760.75
View Details
1887 n172 Old Judge Fred Lange SGC 30 RARE
$799.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Bill Sowders SGC 5 - EX
$930.00
View Details
1886-1887 Old Judge N172 John Ward #478-5 SGC Authentic Incredible Image HOF.
$3899.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card FRED PFEFFER Chicago White Sox SGC 70 5.5 EX+
$1270.75
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge John Irwin Washington Nationals SGC 7.5 Near Mint+
$2250.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Gus Albert Cleveland Throwing PSA 2
$1015.75
View Details
1887 OLD JUDGE RIP VAN HALTREN VG BAT AT READY WHITE STOCKINGS PSA 3
$960.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Bobby Gilks Cleveland Blues SGC 7 Near Mint - Hobby's best!
$1750.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card Rookie ED DELAHANTY (HOF)!!! Philadelphia, SGC
$25000.00
View Details
1887 1889 N172 Old Judge Baseball Card GEORGE PINKNEY OUTDOORS BROOKLYNS SGC 1.5
$760.75
View Details
1887-90 Goodwin Old Judge Tobacco N172 Frank Dwyer CGC 1
$471.10
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Albert Mays PSA 2.5 - GD+
$680.00
View Details
N172 Old Judge Players League Frank Dwyer SGC 3 40 VG 1 Year Only Rarity 1890!
$1899.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Bill Farmer PSA 4 - VG/EX
$860.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Otto Schomberg SGC 3 - VG
$690.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Edward Herr PSA 2.5 - GD+
$640.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Dad Clarke PSA 3 - VG
$810.00
View Details
1887-1890 N172 Old Judge California Brown
$317.95
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Pete Hotaling SGC 4 - VG/EX
$790.00
View Details
1887-1890 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Tommy Tucker & Chris Fulmer, Baltimore Orioles
$2.75
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Samuel Wise PSA 3 - VG
$810.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Robert Gilks PSA 4.5 - VG/EX+
$870.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge C.H. WILLIS - SGC 5.5 EX+
$958.50
View Details
1887-90 Old Judge N172 25 Card Starter Set 4 - VG/EX BSET
$14640.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge Goodwin Baseball Card DAD CLARKE Chicago SGC 4 VG/EX
$1100.75
View Details
1887-1890 Old Judge N172 REPRINT: Jack Glasscock, Indianapolis Hoosiers (N.L.)
$2.85
View Details
1887 N172 OLD JUDGE ELMER FOSTER NEW YORK METS HORIZONTAL PERFECT PICTURE SHARP
$5000.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Otto Schomberg SGC 5 - EX
$1130.00
View Details
1887-90 Old Judge N172 50 Card Starter Set 3.5 - VG+ BSET
$24970.00
View Details
Very rare 1887 Old Judge N172, Charles Bastian, catching, looking up, Philadelph
$668.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Charlie Sprague - SGC 7 NM Chicago White Stockings
$1705.50
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Bierbauer & Gamble Scarce 2 Player Athletics SGC 2
$1500.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Honest John Boyle PSA 2.5 - GD+
$860.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 William Holbert PSA 3 - VG
$800.00
View Details
1887-90 N172 Old Judge James Williams (Manager, Cleveland) SGC 8 NM/MT
$12500.00
View Details
1887 N172 Old Judge **Pud GALVIN (HOF)** Baseball Card!!! Pittsburgh Allegheny's
$4500.00
View Details
1887-90 Old Judge N172 25 Card Starter Set 3 - VG BSET
$11970.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Jack Clements PSA 2 - GOOD
$540.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Jack Clements SGC 4 - VG/EX
$830.00
View Details
1887 Old Judge N172 Jack Clements SGC 3 - VG
$690.00
View Details